jchamberlin
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jul 19, 2010
- Messages
- 1,842
- Location
- Farmville, North Carolina
- displayname
- Jeremiah Chamberlin
Patrick F: Charlie isn't telling you the whole story. There are special punches designed to dislodge old, rusted-in, roll pins; they're called Roll Pin Punches. There is a write-up in the Machine Shop about them. Check out this link: HERE
I've used them and they work great! Basically, there is a "ball" on the end that pushes the center rolls first and kind of relieves the pressure so that you can get the pin started out. The problem with a regular flat pin punch is that before you can get it started, the end off the pin mushrooms, and then you can't ever get it started.
Old hands like Charlie know this and can account for it by getting it started WELL before it mushrooms. In other words, he and others are skilled in the use of a BFH or "Swing Arm Press" or whatever you want to call it. And he's right, the PB Blaster, Kroil, WD-40 or the penetrant of your choice goes a long way to getting it started, which is the most important step.
I made a mess of the pins on my driveshaft the first time I tried to get them out, I was convinced that I would have to buy a new drive shaft and end pieces until my son, the Machinist Mate in the Navy tells me, "Hey Dad, we use those things all the time on the ship, they're nothing." He proceeded to get both of them out in a few minutes with a regular pin punch! --Made me feel stupid I got the roll pin punch set anyway, for those times he's not around, they make the job much easier!
I've used them and they work great! Basically, there is a "ball" on the end that pushes the center rolls first and kind of relieves the pressure so that you can get the pin started out. The problem with a regular flat pin punch is that before you can get it started, the end off the pin mushrooms, and then you can't ever get it started.
Old hands like Charlie know this and can account for it by getting it started WELL before it mushrooms. In other words, he and others are skilled in the use of a BFH or "Swing Arm Press" or whatever you want to call it. And he's right, the PB Blaster, Kroil, WD-40 or the penetrant of your choice goes a long way to getting it started, which is the most important step.
I made a mess of the pins on my driveshaft the first time I tried to get them out, I was convinced that I would have to buy a new drive shaft and end pieces until my son, the Machinist Mate in the Navy tells me, "Hey Dad, we use those things all the time on the ship, they're nothing." He proceeded to get both of them out in a few minutes with a regular pin punch! --Made me feel stupid I got the roll pin punch set anyway, for those times he's not around, they make the job much easier!