Mr. Ide: I respectfully disagree with you on the capacitor issue.
Furthermore, and I think your reasoning is flawed in the following ways.
1. You're taking yourself too seriously. This is a forum, not the Gospel of Matthew, Mark, Luke, or John. ANYTHING posted here is evaluated based on (a) who is posting and what their reputation is (I guess I should be complimented if you consider my advice a threat to the integrity of the forum), and (b) how many posts receive the same "votes" of affirmation. Right now, I guess you have more votes than me, so you're ahead, but I'm not conceding anything, because . . .
2. This is a CAPACITOR we're talking about, the critical criteria have already been discussed. Whether or not it is produced by IH or its heirs is fairly inconsequential. Are you really suggesting that a restoration is going "lose points" because they don't have an "original" capacitor? Are the Correct Police checking the values, now and making sure that "Delco-Remy" appears on the part?
3. In the larger scheme of things, I was trying to help the guy, for crying out loud. I think its been proven that the "Correct Police" approach does more to discourage restorations than encourage them. Getting picky over details like this tends to create an atmosphere that is decidedly "unfriendly" to newcomers. In other words, its not good for business.
So, you can post away with whatever comments you want to make, it is a Forum after all. For my part I will try to preface my comments with, "For what its worth," "I think that," "In a pinch, try," "xxx worked for me." And in the end, that is all I was trying to do for a fellow forum member, suggest an alternative source for capacitors <u>that had worked for me</u>.
Rant over, you can go back to your regularly scheduled programming, I'm going for a walk (now that I'm all charged up), and then I'll head to Mass to ask forgiveness of my sins and leading the faithful on a path of shame.
Edit: I will concede the point about the length of the lead; I had to extend mine, so the restoration would lose points over the butt connector.