KENDELL - Saw all Your comments about "Hardware Store" steel & alum. My guess is that it's ALL imported steel anymore. There's two types of "Imported" raw materials. Most of the angle iron I buy for welding projects says "Made IN Canada" and is of great quality. Lot of imported metals from Europe are fine, Machine shop I bought several Million Dollars worth of parts from every year used almost exclusively European Brass, mostly from Switzerland. There were a couple US mills they'd buy from but the one mill, a "Sole Source" for one family of My parts they had constant quality problems with.
My guess is the source for the hardware store steel & alum. is CHINA. I just got a new FARM SHOW magazine yesterday and the one comment in "Nominate Your Best & Worst Buys" is priceless. That section is always a MUST READ. Guy bought a replacement #50 roller chain replacement sprocket for His silage chopper. Took two hours to remove the old worn sprocket that had lasted for decades, hour and a half to install the new replacement sprocket, and two hours to totally destroy the new sprocket when the questionable steel & heat-treatment caused ALL the teeth to bend and roll over so the sprocket became an idler. Even though most of the new steel, iron, copper/brass, aluminum, etc. processing plants are located in that country they Really haven't figured out how to compete in the World-Wide Marketplace. The bad taste of their dismal quality lingers in the mouth of the Buyer forever while the thoughts of the "Good Deal" fades away the instant the part fails.
Last driveshaft I put in My CC 72 I was going to make from 5/8" dia. STRESSPROOF steel. Everyone do a Google search if You've never heard of it. Then search for 1018 Cold Rolled steel and compare mechanical properties. I still have the Stressproof steel bar, but installed a driveshaft from Midwest SuperCub made from pre-hardened 4130 bar. You compare the spec's for the MWSC 4130 shaft and they're almost identicle to the Stressproof. I can't say how long the MWSC shaft will last, Last OEM shaft I bought was totally shot after 14-15 yrs. The MWSC shaft is only two yrs old.
My guess is the source for the hardware store steel & alum. is CHINA. I just got a new FARM SHOW magazine yesterday and the one comment in "Nominate Your Best & Worst Buys" is priceless. That section is always a MUST READ. Guy bought a replacement #50 roller chain replacement sprocket for His silage chopper. Took two hours to remove the old worn sprocket that had lasted for decades, hour and a half to install the new replacement sprocket, and two hours to totally destroy the new sprocket when the questionable steel & heat-treatment caused ALL the teeth to bend and roll over so the sprocket became an idler. Even though most of the new steel, iron, copper/brass, aluminum, etc. processing plants are located in that country they Really haven't figured out how to compete in the World-Wide Marketplace. The bad taste of their dismal quality lingers in the mouth of the Buyer forever while the thoughts of the "Good Deal" fades away the instant the part fails.
Last driveshaft I put in My CC 72 I was going to make from 5/8" dia. STRESSPROOF steel. Everyone do a Google search if You've never heard of it. Then search for 1018 Cold Rolled steel and compare mechanical properties. I still have the Stressproof steel bar, but installed a driveshaft from Midwest SuperCub made from pre-hardened 4130 bar. You compare the spec's for the MWSC 4130 shaft and they're almost identicle to the Stressproof. I can't say how long the MWSC shaft will last, Last OEM shaft I bought was totally shot after 14-15 yrs. The MWSC shaft is only two yrs old.