Herbert- that's common, and as Charlie says- there's usually something down there at fault.
See the picture that Charlie posted? Up on the top-side of the channel (as it's shown in the picture) is a collar that's actually pressed into, and spot-welded to the channel. There's a thick one in the front (it's been drilled for a roll-pin to retain the axle pivot pin) and a rear one (that's narrow, not drilled). On the ones I've dealt with, that rear collar has broken off (welds weren't sufficient in my observation) and the collar fell off in the yard somewhere. My solution was to get another collar (removed from shot frame, or manufactured from round stock) and install it back into the frame, weld in place. To get the pin alignment correct, I installed an axle and pin into the frame, then slid the collar over the back end of the pin, clamped it in place, then tacked it in place with the MIG welder, disassembled the works, and finish-welded all the way around. Haven't had one come off.
If that doesn't solve your problem, then you've got some other problem. I'd question the fit of your replacement bolt- the OEM pin fit the axle pretty tight... an average-joe-hardware bolt might not fit as tight...
In any event, I just haven't seen a situation where tightening up the channel, or using a tightening bolt, really would improve the situation- that pin fits the axle so tight, and the welded-in channel collars, so there's just nothing down there that will allow that axle to pivot on anything other than the horizontal plane. Even on something like my end-loader tractor- it's just a factory pin in a channel, and although neither of the collars had broken off, I did finish the weld all 'round the collar, and it's tight-as-can-be... pivots on the pin's axis, but no other axis. I'd say there's something else wrong.
Which model IH Cub Cadet tractor is this?
(Message edited by dkamp on January 16, 2005)