STEVE B. - Too bad about the "New Firestone's" not weathering well. That's a complaint I've heard about LOTS of molded rubber parts the last few years. Like molded rubber OEM tie rod end boots on big ag tractors that lasted 30+ yrs, and when the tractor is restored, and new imported OEM boots installed, they crack in less than a year and fall off.
The 23-8.50 'Stones on my 72 were some of the "Next-to-last" run Firestone made, when I ordered them just weeks before PD #1, there were THREE tires left in the HUGE Firestone '79th Street warehouse in Chicago. And there was one more run made after that, I saw a post here years ago somebody bought a new pair of them after I did and long before Miller had molds, not sure how many they made, maybe 100? Maybe 1000? maybe ten? Don't know and Any of the contacts I used to have @ Firestone retired LONG ago.
JOHN L. - WHICH big Firestone Auto tire problem? There's been several. One of the first was the Firestone 500 recall back in 1978, ten Million tires recalled. then the Firestone/Ford Exploder fiasco in 2000 with six million tires recalled. And there's been other issues. And also issues with almost all other brands of tires as well. Some were definitely defective tires, some poor maintenance, or vehicle over-loading.
I've had tires on F150's of the same model as the problem tires on the Explorer's, just the proper size for the F150, and had excellent service from them, had Firestone SteelTex radials on my current pickup that were also recalled, but mine lasted 95,000 miles before I replaced them with Firestone Wilderness A/T's, which lasted 127,000 miles. Yes, I'm easy on tires, and monitor their condition frequently, and adjust inflation pressure in relation to anticipated loads I'm hauling, that's why I get 3-4 times the typical tread life from them. Right now, I have Firestone's on the wife's car, & Bridgestone (new owner of Firestone since 1988) on my car & truck, only TWO 4.00/4.80X8 GY tires left here, frt ties on my #72, and they're a decade past needing replaced due to weather checking and deterioration, but they still hold air after being patched numerous times.
Worst tires I've EVER had? Set of four Good Year Aqua-Tred tires on a '93 Lincoln Continental, bought the car used with them on with only 4-5 thousands miles on the tires. After owning the car only a year, driving on a trip on the Interstate running 65-70 MPH, pulled into a motel 400 miles from home, carried our luggage into the room, returned to the car to go eat and the right frt tire was FLAT. Replaced the tire, drove home and went to visit my friendly local GY store. Since I was not the original buyer of the tires they did not want to warranty them. Then they wanted to only replace three of the four after finding breaks in the tire casings of only three tires. I'm getting more aggravated all the time, they finally agree to put four new Aqua-Tred II tires on the car for just the cost of mounting them. While I sat in the tire store show room for TWO hours, two more people came in with the SAME problem with the SAME Aqua-Tred tires. You never hear of THAT little problem!
Then there was the GY Gator Back tire, factory equipment on Ford Mustang GT's & T-Birds, 140+ MPH capable cars... wife blew out the left rear tire one morning a block from our house doing 25 MPH. We did "walk the street" and found a small piece of steel that was probably kicked up by the frt tire and just grazed the sidewall of the rear tire which caused the blow-out, but the HASSLE the local GY stores (all owned & managed by the same person) was unbelievable. They had a FULL page newspaper ad for their Grand-Opening of a new store sale with my tire 25% off that they would not honor on one tire. After threatening to contact the local Better Business Bureau and going to Farm & Fleet for four new tires for less than they wanted to charge me for ONE tire, they saw things my way. I did NOT appreciate the arrogance of their sales force, was not the first or last time I had issues with that chain of GY stores. Since that time I've bought exactly TWO new GY tires, two frt tires to match the two rear tires on a FWD Chevy Lumina sedan that had 62,000 miles on it. Never rotated tires, frt were wore out, rears looked like new. When I traded the car @ 80,000 miles the salesman allowed more for the car because it had, "Four new tires". I didn't argue with him, that car stickered for $27,000, and 50 months & 80,000 miles later he was allowing us a Whole $5000 in trade on a new $37,000 SUV. Last GM car I'll ever own, would have been cheaper for me to Rent a car from Avis or Hertz than drive that tin can!
So yes, I can understand having a "Bad taste in your mouth" about problems with a certain brand, but you have to "pick your brands" carefully now, they ALL have problems, some just get much more publicity than others. Just depends on if the recalls are announced on a "slow news day" and get hyped more than recalls on busy news days.
On all the ag related and L&G boards I visit, without a doubt, Firestone ag tires are recommended as being the best in pulling power/traction, durability, and quality. The ONLY tire that comes close is Michelin radials, and they're MUCH more expensive, like 35% more than a comparable Firestone. And Michelin does not have a "Mean Machine".